If the valet/ cook did it, wouldn’t he know where the guy lived?

“Nah I promise I’m mega het, look at this sexy woman nightgown and a female locket, I’m super straight”

Maybe it wasn't a "hug murder".... maybe the killer pointed the gun at him and told him to put his hands up and turn around, because the killer couldn't look him in the face and pull the trigger.. idk

I love that Ryan accuses Shane of taking "the easy way out" when it comes to explanations. He thinks his wind theory is the easy way out for ghosts and Shane shut him down. Not the season for it!

Do Kevin cooper

cinematography this episode was amazing! these keep getting better and better

top tier.

yote

charløtte yeet

Ryan, please stop with that Narrator voice. You can't pull it off. :)

the way Ryan narrates is like Gus Abelgas XD

The visualization of the murders and the narration are on point! It's a nice way of storytelling. As for Shane, his commentary serves as our view. Because he is listening to them like us. Overall the show is just superb!

Oo I’m Fromm Carlow

(phone drops)

Ryan's narrator voice makes me giggle

I am loving this noir stuff

22:19

So he was facing up when he was found..... ok so then the hugging then shot makes sense cause then he’s fallen back or helped down but the arms raised (back towards the shooter) doesn’t make sense other wise he’d be faced down.....

Gotta remember people didn't jump to conclusions then like today. Then people didn't automatically assume the worst or point fingers quickly unlike people today.

Okay so when there is Ricky goldsworth?

GUYS ME AND WILLIAM DESMOND TAYLOR HAVE THE SAME BIRTHDAY THATS FREAKY

Arms raised that could be hugging or just hands up or I’ll shoot

I do know some who took the name of her deceased sister.

It will remain unsolved. All suspects should be dead by now or zombified :P

Sands Undrtle

I do think it was Juliet´s mother hiring someone to do it, heck i even think it was her lover who did it for her and if im right that is taking a great risk on your career for a woman

Oh god that telephone ring made me jump

I had my volume up high with headphones and so the goldsworth bit was like weird ASMR 😂

“..shot him while embracing him-“ *immediately gets up to hug*

Maybe shelby saw the pink nightgown in taylors apartment and decided to shoot him

The Minter lady could have very well been involved, who ordered the murder of Taylor. So it would make sense (in a way) if the actual killer was heard in the back yard, smoking.

Ricky is scary

um why wasn't the cigarettes found in the alley ever looked into further? like fingerprints or seeing if one of the suspects smoked those kinds of cigarettes? were they kept as evidence for DNA testing in the future? I feel like this was a missed opportunity to link someone to the case!!

20:23 😎

Ricky Goldsworth strikes again

I can’t believe Sans Undertale killed someone

here is a good one to do on unsolved do the black dahlia murder?

Steven Jeffries It was already done. Check Buzzfeed Unsolved: True Crime Season 1.

LA Noire

lmao they brought in a whole detective and a quote to say that a pink night gown likely belonged to a girl

What if Taylor was hugging someone, but not the person who shot him? Like if someone walked in, saw him with another person and shot Taylor from behind? It would explain him being on his back as the person hugging him might have panicked and let him fall backwards.

What about Margaret Gibson's alleged confession ?

Why cameramen or press reporters yelling at dead body 🤔🤔

I love how at 2:00 he says not calling William Desmond Taylor’s talent into question. When he JUST called his talent into question like 5 seconds before.

the description of the man who was seen leaving made me feel like he was low-key trying to draw attention with his fancy outfits and how he looked back. idk im half asleep and i just feel like you would try to look more casual after you murder someone.

16:02 for me later

I fall asleep to Ryan's theory voice

Ladies and gentlemen, the birth of Ricky goldsworth

youtube ads i get it hannah grace is releasing

Maybe mclean was payed to give a fake testimony about what she saw

Homosexual

I do t get how people can give such detailed accounts of how people look in terms of criminals. Like I never estimate weight and height when I see someone in the heat of the moment 😂

4:37 ;)

"Lets get a load of this bloody man!" Ksjsksksksks

If he was to hug Charlotte, he wouldn’t have had his arms up because she was most likely shorter than him. So if he really was shot with his arms up, Charlotte wouldn’t be the culprit

This episode isn’t that scary as far as the story goes, but Ryan’s *Theory Voice* seems extra creepy (good creepy) and the film noir aesthetic really made it unsettling.

*D E F L O W E R E D*

*You're gonna be my butler. LOL! ✅😂*

24:18 STRAWBERRY! I love BuzzFeed. :P

why do i think they keep saying "sans"?

Weeze hehehe

That coded letter, I know that code, I tried to solve it but it was just random gibberish. Fun.😑

homeboy ryan is literally responsible for the greatest youtube series but cant pronounce February correctly *sigh*

Ohh... mmm... Ryan: What the sh*t

I won’t ever eat at Arby’s again though they gave me food poisoning… Didn’t make for a very pleasant date at the mall. We never made it to the movie. Thank God we took separate cars because we both just want to rush home and get it out.

This format is boring and unnecessarily prolonged.

Lol

The hugging itself between themselves is so awkward hahaha

who played pd cause from what i saw hes cute

This was 1922. Heroine, and Cocaine were legal until 1924. Reefer was the rage at Hollywood parties. They weren't called the Roarin' Twenties for nothing, those flappers knew how to party!

14:26 Sans always knows >;3

that hug reenactment was completely unnecessary but totally wholesome

Why couldn’t they just test the saliva on the cigarettes?

I love " a silent film star, who was vocal "

"asdfghjkl" hOW DID HE MAKE THAG NOISE WITH HIS M O U T H

\\Sometimes people get murdered at Hollywood// Hahahahaha just trying to make it easy

Who would have known that Murder is scandalous?

Salisbury is pronounced "Solls-bree", by the way...

They saw a white male leave, pink women's clothing left at the apartment, she wore a disguise on her way out! You say there were loads of actors in the apartment, actors, makeup........... Easily done.

Ryan sound fuckin crazy in this episode. He sounds like he was way to close to the mic and he was trying to sound extra sPoOkY

I can’t get over Ryan’s little ‘hehehe’ at the start of the video 😂

I've never heard someone say asdfghjkl in real life. Now I feel enlightened. (3:29)

Did—did Shane just keysmash out loud?

I looked out of curiosity, and the $78 left in his wallet would be $1,174.11 today. Guy was loaded, im surprised the murderer didn't rob him too.

that keysmash at 3:28 tho lmao

Shane, you can dine with this Hindu princess anytime. ❤️

My suspect no.5 is they maid

She probably held him hostage in his own house and then he tried to escape so she shot him

this is totally unrelated to anything, but WHENEVER ryan says "sands" i hear sans. i'm so fucking angry

(phone drops)

BRO I RECOGNIZE THAT CODE!!! I don't know what it's called but I know how it works. I've used for passing notes in class

I can't get over the way Ryan said February and homosexual oml XDD

I hate it how ppl discuss about how funny both of them are but not realize how dicusting these things are

0:49 Me: *Scrolls through comments* I'm ready to see the comments about this! *5 seconds later* Me: Nah, I'll just sing the song instead.

ive honestly seen this a few times since it aired haha, and i still crack up so much at Shane's "a dame huh? i'll cover up a murder for her as long as she's smoochin' me" hahahaha so easy for the DA to cover up a few details for her, especially back then without any back ups, just a few files or photos with relevant evidence

Shane isnt wrong in citing La Confidential haha, its not far off at all. The cops in the town were extreeeeeemely corrupt by there being so much money in the area to grease their palms, if youre rich you can get out of anything.

What about the mystery of the Moon King (King Ludwig)

Well this is a rather dull episo--OH GAWD THAT MANNEQUIN MIME ISN'T WEARING ANY PANTS!!

Okay, look...Ryan's whoooole Ricky Goldsworth act thing, the firmness of the taking over the convo is just, I mean...he's a fffffffucking stud in that moment, he's just, how do I...fuck, no words, it's just...OMG you know

The thing that seems off about the whole " being hugged and then shot" scenario is, wouldn't it be obvious if the person is holding the gun whilst going in for a hug?

I dunno dude I'd write my crush a coded love letter 😂😂

WHY IS RYAN TALKING LIKE THAT

If they were taking evidence to disprove the man was maybe gay, why remove letters proving a heterosexual relationship? See that’s really strange.